What did you think of the 'American Idol' winner? * 584238 responses

America got it right: Taylor deserved to win
71%

Katharine was robbed!
29%

Will you buy an album by either finalist? * 594008 responses

Yes, I'd buy both
18%

Yes, I'd buy Taylor's album
31%

Yes, I'd buy Katharine's album
16%

No, I wouldn't buy either
34%

Best 'American Idol' winner ever? * 592341 responses

Kelly Clarkson
46%

Ruben Studdard
2.2%

Fantasia Barrino
5.4%

Carrie Underwood
30%

Taylor Hicks
17%


http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/12940572/

This is just silly. Elliott was the obvious STAR this season.